When does it (not) make sense to decentralize a project incubator with an Ethereum token?

Ethereum is a platform which enables decentralized projects to publish their products, product components, or to simply make the use of any other existing contracts. The power of such networks (and contracts) comes from the network security which enables the user to avoid the need to trust.

Ethereum is already used as the project incubator by allowing the projects to easily issue a token benefiting from the market-cap and liquidity. It is similar to a stock-market by allowing a free-trade of tokens. Therefore, issuing a token like XIO, which has no defined token functions, simply translates everything that Ethereum already does. Other than raising the funds (and possibly dumping the value once enough money is drained), having a project incubator token has no defined meaning or a purpose on Ethereum.

Most of the Ethereum tokens are “for amusement only”. It is the reason why there are so many useless shitcoins. Buttcoin is the perfect example of an amusement-only shit-coin, created by me. It shows how easy it is to use Ethereum, implement ideas and trade them.

Unfortunately, the only function of such project becomes the control of certain behaviours by the means of manipulation and the gate-keeping. To test this, I will try to list my project incubator idea onto XIO’s network without trolling. The expected result is that it will be ignored, ridiculed, and perhaps censored. Although it may cast some bad light onto the incubator project I am proposing, it will be the great way to learn more while testing the reality of the situation.

The project incubator has to offer something that Ethereum is not offering, by programming it onto Ethereum network. The simplest high-level definition of a project incubator implies (source):

The points that we can take from this high-level definition while developing a token are :

All of these mentioned points can be decentralized by programming a token, while only the points which are formatted as italic do not exist as the feature on the Ethereum block-chain.

The only problem, at the moment, is that adding and re-adjusting the information on the block-chain costs a lot of money. So, for example, it may cost around $5 USD just to add/update general data regarding one single company on the block-chain. Now, to start-off with the project, we would need to add at least 1000 of companies to a block-chain database. The only solution to this problem is to create a general token on the main-network, and simply do all the initial work (coding, adding data etc) on the Ropsten (test) network while revealing the code to the public. The main-network release updates to a decentralized system are done only when it makes sense.

Unfortunately, this means that there has to be a centralized authority, independent of the community, and that it needs to bridge the gap between the real-world and the block-chain by selling/offering the services to a token. This is also something that the mentioned XIO token is trying to do while getting the community involved. However, it does nothing that cannot be done using the web3 interface to Ethereum without a necessity to create a token, other than fund-raising and dumping.

--

--

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store